Collecting old comic books is something that is a bit more complicated than you might think. While the concept of “old” seems rather clear, in the world of comic book collecting it is not so easy. Some collectors consider 1970 and below as “old” while others feel that comics reach that moniker when they are older than 1960. The subjective nature of the comic book business can intimidate the new collector, and make it tough to know what is desirable and what is not.
The first thing you need to understand is that comics are not as old as some other collecting items. The first superhero book was Action Comics #1, which was released in 1938. This comic is now considered to be one of the “Holy Grails” of the comic book world. All of the comics from the 30s and 40s are considered rare and highly desirable. The reason for this is also the driving force behind comic book values - scarcity.
Comics in that era were not printed heavily to start with, and the large number of paper drives the United States had around the war contributed to a large number of collections being donated and destroyed. Add to that the length of time that has passed, and you have a truly scarce product. Any comic book from this time period is valuable.
From 1938 until 1956, comic books are referred to as “Golden Age” comic books. These are all valuable to some degree, and make wonderful additions to any comic book collection. Rarity, condition, and first appearances of major superhero characters can drive the cost of these books sky high.
After the “Golden Age” passed in 1956, The Flash debuted what is now called the “Silver Age” of comics. The books that are in this group are much more dependent on condition than their older counterparts. In some cases, the books can be largely worthless if they are in bad condition. Silver age comic books that are in great condition, however, can be extremely valuable as well.
These two “ages” of comic books comprise the breadth of what is considered old in the comic book industry. If you are able to secure these comic books in great condition, then it is highly advised that you get them graded to “lock in” their grade and condition. This adds a ton of value to the book, and can in some cases triple the value or more.
Collecting old comic books is a great hobby, and is sure to provide you with hours of enjoyment. You can find these books at trade shows, comic book conventions, comic book stores, flea markets, classifieds and even occasionally in your attic. The next time you come across an old comic, consider again before you throw it away. You just might have an Action Comics Number 1 on your hands!
